Talent Acquisition

How to Avoid the 6 Deadly Sins of Internal Recruitment

Elevator number 6

Let's face it—recruiting can be a circus, and too often, internal recruiters end up as the clowns.

Over the past seven years, I've witnessed some of the most cringe-worthy mistakes that can turn your hiring process into a comedy of errors. These blunders not only frustrate hiring managers but also blow up your cost per hire, stretch your time to hire to infinity, and weaken your talent pipeline to a trickle.

But fear not! By avoiding these six common mistakes, you can transform your recruitment process from a disaster into a well-oiled machine.

1. Poor Intake Meeting Documentation → Unclear Requirements

The Mistake: Skimping on detailed documentation during intake meetings.

The Consequence: Unclear job requirements lead to a chaotic hiring process where no one knows what they're looking for.

Why It Happens: Often, recruiters rush through intake meetings, jotting down vague notes that fail to capture the nuances of the role. This results in a mismatch between what the hiring manager expects and what the recruiter delivers.

Best Practice: Conduct thorough intake meetings where you drill down into the specifics. Use structured forms to capture critical details such as required skills, experience, and cultural fit. By investing time upfront, you ensure that everyone is on the same page. This reduces the risk of miscommunication and aligns expectations.

2. Not Involving Incumbents in Kick-Off → Lacklustre Messaging

The Mistake: Excluding current employees from the recruitment kick-off process.

The Consequence: Recruitment messages that fall flat and fail to attract top talent.

Why It Happens: Recruiters often overlook the value that incumbents can bring to the table. These employees understand the role better than anyone else and can provide insights that make your messaging more compelling.

Best Practice: Involve incumbents in the kick-off meetings. Their firsthand experience can help you craft messages that resonate with potential candidates. This approach not only enhances your job descriptions but also ensures that your communication is authentic and engaging.

3. Using Recruitment Agencies → Damage to Brand Perception

The Mistake: Over-reliance on external recruitment agencies.

The Consequence: Potential candidates receive mixed messages and develop a poor perception of your brand.

Why It Happens: While agencies can help fill positions quickly, they might not always align with your company’s values and culture. This disconnect can lead to a disjointed candidate experience.

Best Practice: Build an internal recruitment team that understands and embodies your brand. When you need to use agencies, choose partners who are aligned with your values and provide them with comprehensive briefings to ensure they represent your brand accurately.

4. Poor UX on Application Workflow → Poor Quality Inbound

The Mistake: Neglecting the user experience (UX) of your application process.

The Consequence: High drop-off rates and low-quality applications.

Why It Happens: Companies often overlook the candidate experience during the application process. Lengthy forms, unclear instructions, and cumbersome interfaces can frustrate candidates and deter them from completing their applications.

Best Practice: Streamline your application process. Use technology to simplify the workflow, making it intuitive and user-friendly. Consider implementing features like auto-fill and resume parsing to reduce friction. A positive candidate experience not only increases the quantity of applications but also improves their quality.

5. Over-Reliance on 360 Model → Bottlenecks Everywhere

The Mistake: Depending too heavily on a 360-degree recruitment model where recruiters handle every aspect of the hiring process.

The Consequence: Bottlenecks and inefficiencies that slow down the hiring process.

Why It Happens: The 360 model can be effective, but it often leads to overload. Recruiters juggling multiple roles—from sourcing to onboarding—can become stretched too thin, leading to delays and decreased effectiveness.

Best Practice: Adopt a more specialized approach. Divide the recruitment process into distinct roles, such as sourcing specialists, interview coordinators, and onboarding managers. This allows each team member to focus on their area of expertise, increasing efficiency and reducing bottlenecks.

6. Not Tracking Message Conversions → Flying Blind

The Mistake: Failing to track the effectiveness of your recruitment messages.

The Consequence: Inability to measure what works and what doesn’t, leading to a scattergun approach to recruitment.

Why It Happens: Without tracking, it’s impossible to know which messages resonate with candidates and which fall flat. This lack of insight can lead to repeated mistakes and missed opportunities.

Best Practice: Implement robust tracking mechanisms. Use analytics tools to monitor the performance of your messages and adjust your strategy based on the data. By understanding what works, you can refine your approach and improve your recruitment outcomes.

Wrapping Up

Avoiding these six mistakes can revolutionize your recruitment process. Here’s a quick recap:

  1. Document Intake Meetings: Ensure clear and detailed job requirements.
  2. Involve Incumbents: Craft compelling and authentic messages.
  3. Limit Agency Use: Maintain brand integrity and consistent messaging.
  4. Optimize UX: Enhance the candidate experience for better applications.
  5. Specialize Roles: Increase efficiency and reduce bottlenecks.
  6. Track Conversions: Measure effectiveness and continuously improve.

By getting these elements right, you’ll see a significant improvement in your recruitment outcomes. Frustrated hiring managers will turn into happy collaborators, costs will be controlled, hiring times will shorten, and your talent pipeline will overflow with quality candidates.

So, step up your recruitment game and watch your organization thrive. After all, who wants to be the clown in the recruitment circus?


Move's embedded talent service ensures you get it right when you most need to. We’re experts at securing top talent that thrives in early-stage tech businesses. And, we’ll set you up for hiring success so you can do it without us in the future 🚀 Work with your own dedicated, expert talent team on a subscription basis during periods of growth. No long contracts. Guaranteed hires.

We’ll make the hires, you keep the playbooks 🛠🤝 Don't take our word for it, check out our testimonials page 👀🚀🚀

Share on :
vector 4 svgvector 3 svg

Related Blogs